Friday, December 6, 2019

Grandma Marian's "White Salad"

As I mentioned a couple of posts ago, we hosted the traditional Thanksgiving Dinner at our house last  Thursday.  I'm sure everyone has a different list of what is considered the traditional Thanksgiving menu, but for my family it is always the same:

Turkey and Gravy
Mashed Potatoes
Candied Sweet Potatoes
Cranberry Sauce
Green Bean Casserole
Escalloped Corn
White Salad
Dinner Rolls
Pumpkin Pie with Whipped Cream

This is tradition in our family because this is always what my Grandma Marian served on Thanksgiving.  Today, I want to share with you her recipe for "White Salad."  This is my favorite fruit salad, and when Grandma was still cooking, it was hers too.  My mother and aunt were reminiscing about the fact that she used to take it everywhere.  It is delicious, and it was the first leftover to be finished off.  I don't know why I don't make it more often because it's really not difficult either.

Here is what you'll need:

  • 2 eggs
  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • 1/4 cup distilled vinegar
  • Non-dairy whipped topping (thawed) or slightly sweetened whipped cream (about a cup and a half).
  • 1 15oz. can of mandarin oranges
  • 1 15oz. can of pineapple tidbits
  • red and green grapes (at least a cup of each)
  • at least 1 cup of miniature marshmallows
  • red cherries for garnish (optional)


Early in the morning or the night before the meal, you will need to make the first part of the salad dressing.

1. Have your fire hot enough to boil a little bit of water in the bottom of a double boiler.

2. Before putting it over the hot water, lightly beat two eggs in the top part of the double boiler.

3. Beat in the 1/4 cup of sugar and the 1/4 cup of distilled vinegar.

4.  Once thoroughly combined, put the top of the double boiler over the boiling water.

5. Stirring constantly, cook until it has thickened enough that it coats a spoon.

6. Remove from the heat and cool slightly.  Cover, then chill thoroughly in the refrigerator.  (This doesn't take that long because there really isn't that much volume here.)

7. While the dressing is chilling and long before you plan to assemble the salad, wash the grapes and cut them in half.  Place them on paper towels to dry.  Also drain the cans of mandarin oranges and pineapple tidbits.  Let them rest in a colander for quite a while.  You want the fruit to be as dry as possible.

8. Once the cooked part of the dressing is thoroughly chilled, beat the whipped topping or the whipped cream into the custard part.  The directions for the amount of whipped topping literally say "until it looks right" on the recipe that I copied from Grandma.  This was the phrase that she and her mother both used when they tried to tell someone else how they cooked by guess and by golly.

I don't really think you can mess up this part.  If you want to make this salad larger by adding more fruit, you can always add more whipped topping to the custard at this step.  The only thing that will happen is that the sweet and sour flavor of the dressing will tend toward the sweeter side.

In the pictures here, I would say that I added about one and a half cups of whipped topping.

9. Combine the fruits and then fold in the dressing.

10. Add about a cup of miniature marshmallows.  DON'T SKIP THIS STEP in an effort to cut back on the calories.  The value of the marshmallows is not so much in the flavor as it is in their ability to absorb the juices which will be drawn out of the fruit.  Their primary function is to keep the salad from turning watery.

11. If desired, garnish the top of the salad with a red cherry or more.  Refrigerate until serving.

The last picture above didn't get taken until the salad had been passed around the table once.  That's why a chunk of the salad is missing on the right side.

You will note that the salad dressing doesn't appear very white.  That's because my chickens are free range, so their egg yolks are darker than what you would get out of the store.

This is really an excellent fruit salad: tangy, sweet, and colorful.  Bon appetit!


  1. Okay, I was skeptical at first, but upon reading it seems that this is a close cousin to the Frog Eye Salad that my family likes so much. Instead of adding vinegar to a custard base, that recipe uses the reserved pineapple juice to make more of a pineapple curd than a custard. Many similarities, though, and I can see how this would be a favorite.

    How is it that you've never fed me this salad and I've probably never fed you Frog Eye? Clearly, we all are not breaking bread - or spooning salad - together nearly often enough.

    1. I don't make this salad often enough, largely because Grandma always did it and I didn't have to. That's why you've never had it served to you.

      You are the better friend, however, and have served me Frog Eye Salad--which I love. You are right about the dressings being similar.